Throughout my pregnancy with Lily, one of the things I looked forward to was using cloth full-time on a newborn. I did use cloth diapers some with Abby in the first weeks, but it was always easier to use disposables since most of my stash was flats at the time. In fact, I was so excited about using cloth diapers period by the time she got here because Abby had been battling a horrific diaper rash the month or so before Lily was born! (Yes, it finally did go away! SUN/MAD RASH by theBALM was our miracle cream.)
I do want to preface this tell-all review with some basic information. Lily was born at 8 pounds, 13 ounces, and she had grown to 10 pounds, 7 ounces, by her 2-week checkup. Her thighs have been chunky since she was about 2 weeks old, too. Another factor in my preferences is that she has been a heavy wetter since birth, but unlike most exclusively breastfed babies, she doesn’t poop after every. single. feeding. Sometimes it’s once a day, sometimes it’s once every two days. It’s mostly normal, and she rarely shows any signs of pain or discomfort when she poops. In other words, if you have skinny babies with chicken legs who poop every time they eat, expect a much different outcome.
Before I even got pregnant, I knew that I would have a great newborn stash simply because Melissa was given about 27 newborn prefolds in the amazing stash-builder box! She also had about 5 covers to share. That, along with my 2 covers that I used with Abby and the covers that I reviewed made about 9 covers. My favorite covers for newborns are the Thirsties Duo Wraps because they snap down smaller than the x-small Thirsties covers but last twice as long!
I honestly didn’t like using the prefolds as much as I had hoped. Lily wet so much so fast that her little bottom would be red in no time in these. My only other option was to change her diapers every hour or so. Thankfully, we had a few other options.

Along with the prefolds and covers, I had 4 fitted diapers. These were all review diapers. I didn’t have the Clover fitted for the first week or so, but it was by far the most absorbent one in my stash. However, like the prefolds, these would get wet, stay wet, and feel wet on Lily’s bottom. They all needed to be changed quickly, and I often found them soaked all the way through anyway. In fact, while I had planned on leaving her uncovered while in fitteds some, I never did because she would soak through the fitted with her first pee!
My favorite combination, though, was a Clover fitted and a fleece cover. The fleece not only allowed Lily’s bum to breathe but it also seemed to stay dryer for longer than any other diaper at the time!
The final bit of my newborn stash? Pockets and all-in-ones! I had 4 BumGenius newborn all-in-one diapers, 2 AppleCheeks Size 1 pocket diapers, and 1 discontinued Swaddlebees pocket diaper to begin with. Lily’s first diaper, put on just minutes after birth, was a BumGenius newborn AIO in Grasshopper. *swoon!* I found over and over again that even though I still had to change Lily more frequently due to how quickly she wet a diaper, my pockets and all-in-ones were the first diapers that I turned to. After all, if I had to change them frequently, I may as well be using the easiest diapers to put on or take off! These were especially nice for nighttime changes, since there wasn’t anything to cover or “finagle.”
Lily was practically sleeping through the night by about 4 weeks (she wakes up once or twice during the night), and I found that the most absorbent diapers for this time were my AppleCheeks. I used the bamboo inserts, and she stayed dry through most of the night. I recently started putting her in one-size pockets at night, though, because the AppleCheeks aren’t holding in all her pee anymore!

There is one cloth diaper that isn’t pictured here, and it’s a new favorite of mine. I won two Thirsties Duo AIO at a Twitter party after Lily was born, and the size 1 is one that I would highly recommend for a newborn stash. It holds more than most newborn diapers, but it will fit from newborn to around 19 pounds, depending on how chunky your baby’s thighs get. While I’ve already put away the BumGenius newborn diapers (*tear!*), I still have room left in the AppleCheeks, the Swaddlebees pocket, and the Thirsties Duo AIO. Lily is also fitting into all of my one-size diapers pretty well. I’m keeping her diapers separate from Abby’s by paying attention to where the diapers are snapped down and sorting them in separate drawers.
While our newborn stash days are nearly over (and much quicker than most babies), I enjoyed having the itty bitty diapers in the house for my little girl. If you can afford them, I think it’s worth it to have a stash especially for newborns, especially if you’re planning on having more kids! And if you aren’t planning on having more kids, these diapers have a high resale value.
So what am I doing with my newborn stash? I plan on adding to the newborn stash that Melissa has so that it can be shared with others (and if I have more babies, I could use them too). I do plan on selling a couple and keeping a couple (like the BG NB AIO in Lovelace!), but I’ve yet to pick which ones will be sold.
Did you have or are you planning a newborn stash? If so, which diapers are your favorites for itty bitty bums?
